OTHER

Amazon Tackles Data Center Issues by Abolishing NDAs

Matt Garman, CEO of Amazon Web Services, has revealed that the company will discontinue the use of nondisclosure agreements (NDAs) when working with government bodies to obtain approvals for new data center projects.

Garman’s comments are included in a wider blog post aimed at addressing prevalent misconceptions about data centers, highlighting that these facilities generally provide benefits to local communities.

The prevalence of NDAs has significantly contributed to increasing resistance against data centers. Environmental advocate Erin Brockovich has recently expressed her major concern regarding these facilities—their lack of transparency—pointing out an ongoing issue: “Projects are frequently disclosed only after permits are granted, developers rarely provide information, and local officials often sign NDAs before communities are informed about proposed initiatives.”

In response to these escalating worries, New York has imposed a year-long pause on permits for large data center projects. Garman highlighted that there are currently more than 100 moratoriums on data center initiatives being considered across the United States.

“If these actions are taken, the U.S. risks jeopardizing its competitive edge, which could have long-lasting repercussions,” Garman stated. “As a nation, we must avoid reaching such a point.”

Garman also sought to dispel four prevalent myths surrounding data centers: that they dramatically consume water, inflate electricity prices, contribute significantly to pollution, and fail to provide tangible benefits to local communities.

Referencing an Amazon report on water use, Garman observed that “direct water consumption by data centers” accounts for merely 0.5% of the total industrial water usage in the U.S., which is “substantially less than that of golf courses, almond farming, and other sectors.”

Nvidia recently claimed that its advanced cooling technology almost entirely eliminates water usage in data centers; however, such assertions—including those from Amazon—often overlook the broader water implications associated with electricity generation and chip manufacturing. Experts recommend independent assessments of water and energy consumption within data centers, especially given the absence of federal or state reporting requirements for tech companies concerning these factors.

Regarding electricity costs, Garman pointed out that the increases are primarily observed in certain states with a high density of data centers, while other areas have witnessed either reductions or slower rate increases. He argued, “In regions where energy prices are climbing, it’s mainly due to an outdated grid that has not been adequately invested in or expanded to meet demand.”

Conversely, a recent independent study indicated that data centers have significantly contributed to a 76% surge in prices on the largest electric grid in the U.S. over the last year.

On the pollution issue—prompting the NAACP to file a lawsuit against Elon Musk’s SpaceX/xAI—Garman criticized critics for focusing solely on the maximum pollution levels permitted in data center licenses. One instance is a proposed Amazon data center in Texas, which has been authorized to emit 33 million tons of carbon dioxide annually, surpassing emissions from any other power facility in the nation.

“In reality, data center generators are seldom operational,” Garman clarified. “They remain inactive 99.9% of the time (operating for about 10 hours a year, mostly for necessary maintenance checks).”

Regarding community advantages, Garman stated, “We have ceased using nondisclosure agreements with government entities involved in our projects.” He also emphasized that “over the past three years, Amazon has invested more than $1 billion in the U.S. communities where we maintain a significant data center presence.”

Will this be enough to ease community concerns? Perhaps not—Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei recently noted that the resistance against AI signifies “a crisis of trust,” where individuals believe that governments and tech companies continuously “discover new ways to exploit them.” Similarly, writer Jasmine Sun remarked that when critics of data centers hear back from tech companies, their typical response is, “I don’t trust them.”

By clicking on links in our articles, we may earn a small commission. This does not affect our editorial independence.