Can the AI Industry Overcome Data Center Criticism by Discarding NDAs?
Amazon has recently chosen to collaborate with Microsoft by discontinuing the use of nondisclosure agreements (NDAs) in its talks with local governments concerning data centers.
In a recent episode of TechCrunch’s Equity podcast, Sean O’Kane, Rebecca Bellan, and I discussed Amazon’s announcement, which was part of a wider blog post promoting the idea that data centers can positively impact local communities.
Rebecca voiced her doubts about the current trend of data center moratoriums having lasting effects, especially since these moratoriums are typically limited to a year or two, while “these data centers won’t be operational for the next two, three, four, or five years.” In contrast, I maintained that supporters of data centers appear to have genuine concerns.
Sean highlighted that poor communication within the industry significantly contributes to the backlash.
“The ongoing controversies surrounding AI and data centers illustrate that the industry struggles with effective communication, expressing frustration that most people fail to envision scenarios where these technologies are beneficial,” he remarked.
Continue reading for a concise summary of our discussion, streamlined for clarity and brevity.
Sean O’Kane: It’s fascinating that this was somewhat buried in the blog post, part of Amazon’s broader narrative. While I understand why they chose not to emphasize it, I believe it encapsulates many challenges the tech industry is facing—related not only to AI but specifically to data centers.
Numerous conversations arise about public anxieties over data centers’ effects on property values, electricity pricing, and water usage—whether these fears are valid or overblown.
A significant part of the issue is that many of these initiatives are negotiated privately. Sometimes the public knows a data center is on the table, but they lack information about its potential users or occupants.
This has long been a problem in the tech industry. I often recall the mid-2010s when Uber was expanding rapidly. They frequently used these tactics when negotiating with local authorities. I remember a story at The Verge about a town near Orlando where Uber sought tax incentives to encourage rides to public transport after Uber trips.
The entire negotiation took place behind closed doors, which was frustrating, but this secrecy allowed Uber to become more audacious with their requests.
There’s a pressing need for more transparency. I’m glad about Amazon’s choice. Time will tell whether it leads to favorable outcomes, but the current scenario is quite entrenched.
Rebecca Bellan: I’m curious to see how this affects communities and whether it successfully delays or even halts needed infrastructure for these companies. Based on my discussions with those closely engaged with data centers, many of the moratoriums being introduced—like one recently in San Francisco, which is notably ironic—are set for only a year or two.
However, these data centers won’t be functional for the next two, three, four, or five years. Construction schedules may encounter significant delays due to various reasons ranging from zoning disputes to funding challenges. If community opposition persists, it might have an impact, but I often wonder about the actual effectiveness of this political resistance.
Anthony Ha: The moratorium I am most familiar with is in New York, which is for one year, specifically concerning permits for substantial projects. [Technically, it’s until the state completes an environmental review process, which is expected to take a year.]
There’s some leniency in that period. It’s often presented as: “We don’t think [data centers] should be entirely dismissed. We just need to take time to assess this.” This leaves ample room for them to later state, “Actually, we’ve concluded this is beneficial. We fully support it.”
One can sense the anxiety among those trying to establish these data centers, as reflected in the erratic tweets from people like Trump or David Sacks. Only time will reveal the extent and longevity of this [community] opposition, but it’s clear that concerns exist.
It’s also worth noting that Microsoft recently made a similar announcement regarding NDAs. While removing NDAs won’t necessarily persuade opposition groups to alter their positions, it does spark a dialogue about transparency, which is critical since prior negotiations occurred in secrecy. So, it seems to be a promising first step.
Sean: The overarching issue here revolves around communication. This concern permeates the entire tech sector, but it’s particularly noticeable now as we navigate an era of “going direct” and claims that “media is dead.”
I don’t mean to dwell on this, especially since we are in the media and believe we continue to hold relevance. However, through the controversies surrounding AI and data centers, it’s evident that the industry fails to articulate its viewpoint adequately, resulting in ongoing frustration that many individuals can’t conceptualize how these technologies could be advantageous for them—partly due to the [technological] limitations and partly due to poor explanations.
Last week, I wrote about the fact that a year has passed since Tesla last actively championed its mission of achieving what it initially termed “sustainable abundance,” now revamped as “amazing abundance.” It’s astounding to realize a year has gone by with no clear definition provided, despite the release of a lengthy PDF during their announcement, which even Tesla’s staunchest supporters critiqued for being vague. It felt filled with LLM jargon.
Anthony: This situation has led me to reflect on the dominant narrative, which at one point seemed aggressively thrust upon us—indicating that an AI-driven future is unavoidable and that we must acquiesce or risk being left behind.
While that future is progressing in numerous respects, considerable hurdles still exist. What I value about this struggle is the demand for substantiation of claims. You can’t simply declare, “This is the future; accept it.”
Regarding Tesla and the abundance concept, what struck me wasn’t just the lack of a clear definition but the very fact that it was a promise they made initially. This underscores the unique dynamic in our relationship with Tesla, especially among those who fervently support Elon. The focus seems less on the company’s sales achievements and more on its promise to revolutionize society. Or at least, that’s the narrative they are being sold.
When you purchase through links in our articles, we may earn a small commission. This doesn’t affect our editorial independence.


