Are Fusion Startups Trading Government Grants for Equity Making a Smart Move?
The dynamics between the U.S. government and the fusion power industry have seen significant changes, but a strong re-engagement was established last week.
Helion and Commonwealth Fusion Systems (CFS) have successfully obtained $260 million from the Department of Commerce under the CHIPS and Science Act, a 2022 initiative designed to bolster domestic semiconductor production. These funds are intended to aid in the creation of cutting-edge semiconductors crucial for operating their reactors, with Helion receiving $175 million and CFS securing $85 million.
However, similar to many recent governmental funding initiatives, these grants come with particular stipulations. Helion and CFS have consented to provide the government with non-voting shares in return for this financial support. This signifies a refreshed governmental interest in the fusion sector, although in an unexpected format.
Traditionally, government support for startups involved non-dilutive capital, allowing companies to pursue additional funding without diminishing the interests of current investors. This model was favored by investors since it enabled startups to acquire more resources without new financial burdens. Although the government’s goal was to stimulate American innovation, this approach often yielded minimal immediate returns from successful investments.
The Trump administration pushed for a shift in this paradigm.
Minor grants, major implications?
For Helion and CFS, the funding amounts are relatively small compared to their total capital raised. CFS has attracted nearly $4 billion, while Helion is approaching $3.2 billion in commitments. The true importance of these grants may be symbolic, indicating that after years of funding reductions and restrictions for fusion, the U.S. government is once again showing interest in the industry.
Fusion generates energy through atomic fusion, mirroring processes that occur naturally in the sun, and represents a costly venture requiring scarce materials, sophisticated computational models, and complex manufacturing techniques. Over the last decade, private investments have surpassed $14 billion, fueled by hopes that one or more companies will successfully construct a power plant.
Nonetheless, the Fusion Industry Association, representing the sector, highlights that this sudden influx of investment still lags behind international rivals. Last year, the association called for a one-time federal investment of $10 billion, with $5.4 billion designated specifically for fusion startups.
“Other nations are quickly advancing their commercial fusion capabilities, investing billions into government-supported initiatives to dominate the fusion energy landscape,” a representative from CFS informed TechCrunch. CFS is affiliated with the Fusion Industry Association. “The proposed $10 billion investment seeks to enhance the research infrastructure detailed in the DOE’s Fusion Roadmap and rejuvenate the U.S. domestic fusion sector to compete with China.”
Until recently, federal assistance for fusion has been limited. The Biden administration launched the Milestone Based Fusion Development Program through the Department of Energy, providing financial incentives for companies that hit specific technical milestones; however, initial funding was relatively low, totaling under $50 million. Subsequent funding levels have seen gradual increases but still did not meet the Fusion Industry Association’s expectations.
With two companies now receiving $260 million, it seems lobbying efforts are beginning to bear fruit, although in an unexpected form, as the funding is being routed through the Department of Commerce instead of the sought-after research budget of the Fusion Industry Association and has equity conditions attached.
According to a source familiar with the discussions, the Fusion Industry Association’s lobbying efforts did not involve terms for equity stakes in return for support. However, Helion has indicated that the government will obtain $175 million in non-voting equity tied to its Series G funding round, giving the company a valuation of $15.5 billion, equating to about a 1% ownership stake. The government’s equity in CFS will also be non-voting and based on the company’s most recent undisclosed valuation.
“This type of arrangement has become increasingly prevalent in significant investments from the U.S. government in recent years,” stated David Kirtley, co-founder and CEO of Helion, in comments to TechCrunch. “This structure aligns Helion’s interests with those of U.S. taxpayers, linking them to our commercial success.”
A representative from CFS expressed similar sentiments, saying, “This U.S. equity stake will enable taxpayers to share in our commercial achievements as we support the vital research and development necessary to create an American commercial fusion industry.”
Not alone
Helion and CFS are among a select group of companies that have seen the government take a financial interest in exchange for federal funding.
Last year, MP Materials, a major mineral supplier, provided the government a 15% equity stake in return for a $400 million investment, plus a $150 million loan and profit-sharing agreements. Likewise, USA Rare Earth, another essential minerals enterprise, assigned a 10% stake for a $277 million grant and a $1.3 billion loan. Intel set a more controversial precedent by converting $8.9 billion granted by the Biden administration into approximately a 10% equity stake from the Trump administration, a trend that seems to be ongoing.
Internationally, Germany’s Proxima Fusion has confirmed to TechCrunch that both the German government and the European Union hold stakes in the company. It has also secured equity investments from state-backed funds like SPRIND (Germany’s federal agency for disruptive innovation) and DCTF (Deutsche Climate Tech Fonds).
However, not all fusion startups collaborating with the government have agreed to cede equity. Thea Energy and Avalanche Energy, both of which have secured federal funding and contracts, along with Pacific Fusion, which has partnered with federal laboratories, have assured TechCrunch that they have not surrendered any equity to the government. Inertia Enterprises has similarly stated to TechCrunch that it has not provided equity to the government, despite its collaborations with the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory to commercialize fusion technology developed there.
Thus far, only a few startups have opted to offer equity to the government in exchange for funding. However, this emerging trend could establish important precedents within the sector.
With direct financial support for fusion startups, the Trump administration is signaling that fusion energy is a strategic priority for the U.S. This support could boost investor confidence but may also discourage private funding. Venture capitalists will have to assess whether the dilution from a government stake is justifiable based on potential benefits. Additionally, what impact will this have on valuation metrics during future fundraising or business shutdowns? Who will have primacy in such scenarios?
While the fusion industry has attracted billions in recent investments, it will require even greater funding to fulfill its potential. Historically, securing federal grants was a clear pathway to growth. The present dynamics, however, seem more intricate. Will these new agreements ultimately be advantageous?
When you purchase through links in our articles, we may earn a small commission. This doesn’t affect our editorial independence.


